American con artist Thomas Doyle, 68, has been charged with wire fraud for allegedly defrauding London gallery owner Patrick Matthiesen over a Gustave Courbet painting. Doyle claimed to manage a family trust with billions in assets and offered to broker the sale of Courbet's 1844 oil painting *Mother and Child on a Hammock* without commission. Instead, he delivered the work to his partner Shalva Sarukhanishvili, who sold it to Jill Newhouse Gallery for $115,000; the gallery then resold it to collector Jon Landau for $125,000. Matthiesen received no proceeds and filed a lawsuit against Doyle, Sarukhanishvili, Jill Newhouse Gallery, and Landau. Doyle has a prior fraud conviction involving a Corot painting and was described by a judge as a "career criminal."
This case highlights vulnerabilities in the art market, where trust and provenance can be exploited by sophisticated fraudsters. The involvement of multiple galleries and a prominent collector underscores how easily forged documents and false claims can circulate, potentially undermining confidence in art transactions. The legal battle may set precedents for liability among buyers, sellers, and intermediaries when a work's title is contested.